|
|
| You are not logged in, You may post comments with your name above, the name will be attached to the comments but the official poster will be GUEST, Registration is free and takes seconds |
USER:
Guest: kaitlyn :: austin tx |
Date:
2005-03-17 17:39:24 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| omg this is kinda a sad song....but i love this song sooo much....almost as much as mr brightside! |
USER:
Guest: Natalie :: Tx |
Date:
2005-03-22 13:04:37 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| I don't understand this song, I love the killers, but I just don't understand what this song means. If anyone wants to help me out? |
USER:
Guest: Ali :: arkansas |
Date:
2005-04-09 01:19:20 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| ok ok that makes sence but whats up with the hey shut up part? |
USER:
Guest: TheJayrod :: Huntsville, Tx |
Date:
2005-04-07 08:20:24 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| I believe its a song of homosexuality. Correct me if I'm wrong here. And Andy is attempting to hide the fact he is gay (On the match with the boys, you think you're all alone) while the other man wants to openly love him. Just a quick view of my interpretation. |
USER:
Guest: Tezar :: Malaysia |
Date:
2005-04-08 10:08:49 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| is this song about homosexuality...???but the rythm is good n funny!!! |
USER:
Guest: Samantha :: Sebastopol, CA |
Date:
2005-04-18 00:00:29 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| I think this song is definitely about homosexuality. It's clear that the speaker is in love with Andy (you can here the pain in his voice!). But Andy is trying to hide the fact that he is gay. This is where the "hey shut up" comes in. If you listen you can tell "hey shup up" is spoken in a different tone than the rest of the song. Andy is the one telling the speaker to shut up because he doesn't want people to know that he is gay. Also, the speaker asks Andy to leave his number on the locker, which suggests that they are having a secret relationship. Andy is trying to hide who he really is, hence the girl in the car who is essentially just another cover. If you read the song more than once you start to see everything fall into place. Truly this is a sad song! |
USER:
Guest: Anna :: CA |
Date:
2005-04-26 03:46:41 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| you said: "is this song about homosexuality...???but the rythm is good n funny!!! " yes, and it's a great song. there is nothing wrong with homosexuality, so it shouldn't affect how you like it at all. |
USER:
Guest: joe :: austin tx |
Date:
2005-05-12 02:18:26 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| there is something wrong with homosexuality, i hope this group isnt gay cuz i was starting to like the songs and im afraid i will have wasted my money on their cd |
USER:
Guest: ybunhy :: la |
Date:
2005-06-01 02:52:31 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| i love this song. at first when i knew about this group i didnt they were gay after i heard the lyrics but that doesnt matter but the fact is that they're good. it doesnt matter if theyre gay. i love their music |
USER:
Guest: Amanda :: Pa |
Date:
2005-06-01 22:45:43 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| This goes out to Joe: what is wrong with homosexuality? I'm a Christian, but I don't think it's wrong. And who said that the band was gay? Did if every occur to you that the band's message is that prejudice against homosexuals is stupid? Apparently not. |
USER:
Guest: Britt :: NS |
Date:
2005-06-20 18:22:59 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| ON the Killers official website there is a rundown of what each song is about, and this song is not about homosexuality. It is about a stalker. (On the match with the boys, you think you're alone) Andy is a High School football star and the speaker is stalking him. |
USER:
Guest: Nicole |
Date:
2005-05-29 15:23:06 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| Why does it matter on the band or group's sexuality? Oh, wait I forgot. Sexuality determines if you are a "good" or a "person" bad. Ugh, stupid close-minded Christans making other Christans LOOK BAD. Listen, you can have your own mind. You don't have to let society, the bible, or whatever-you-listen-too control your thoughts. |
USER:
Guest: Rosie :: MN |
Date:
2005-05-31 19:51:45 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| I totally agree, just because you're christian doesn't gay people are evil or horrible. and besides if you like the why on earth does it matter |
USER:
Guest: Rosie :: MN |
Date:
2005-05-31 19:50:58 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| I totally agree, just because you're christian doesn't gay people are evil or horrible. and besides if you like the why on earth does it matter |
USER:
Guest: Victoria :: St. Louis |
Date:
2005-06-20 18:45:52 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| hello, the song is about a stalker, not about being gay or anything like that. andy could be a boy or a girl, too. I love this song, it is amazing, thanks britt, for getting it right, and looking into it. i commend you! |
USER:
Guest: kayla :: blandon PA |
Date:
2005-06-06 23:17:55 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| OK people this song isn't about homosexuality it does sound like it at first but if you clearly listen to the song at the beginning it says "One, Two" which means there two people a guy and a girl!! The guy starts and the girl says "Hey shut up" brecause she trying to hide there relationship!! She also sings "In the car with a girl, promise me she not your world" because she loves him, ok!!She also sings "Andy your a star"!! If you listen his voice changes every part to show you that!! The reason a girl isn't sing it is because he is telling the story not her!! (plus theres no girl in the group!!) |
USER:
Guest: dddd :: sydney |
Date:
2005-06-15 05:58:10 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| sorry kayla.. that was lame explanation |
USER:
Guest: dylan :: CA |
Date:
2005-06-16 22:35:13 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| there is defintely something wrong with homosexuality! i don't think this band is gay though. If you pay attention to the lyrics of somebody told me, mr brightside, and jenny was a friend of mine, it's kind of obvious that not all of them are gay. still. this song is really creepy and kinda cheapens the CD. |
USER:
Guest: Josh :: Nephi, Utah |
Date:
2005-06-18 06:16:00 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| This song is about the lead singer. Andy was the big football and wrestling star in our town. He was a bully and would pick on the singer in this song. He is now singing this song to get back at Andy bashing him telling him who really is the star now, NOT ANDY. |
USER:
Guest: jess :: wales |
Date:
2005-07-05 19:32:29 |
| THE KILLERS-Andy, You're A Star |
| i love the killers so would someone please tell me the name of their official site! |
USER:
Guest: Andy :: Md |
Date:
2005-07-11 05:41:28 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| I love this song i definnitly one of my favorites on the Killers "Hot Fuss" Cd. I feel his pain cos i too know what its like to be gay and have a crush on someone who doesnt care about you..I hope Brandon is gay cos that would be totally FABTABULOUS! (totally seventies isn't it) well any way its the best friggin song in the whole entire world and its a good thing Brandon let out his true emotions. |
USER:
Guest: Andy :: Md |
Date:
2005-07-11 05:44:33 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| I agree that gay people are underestimated just because they like guys or gurls. its mean that everyone treats us this way...i mean seriously do u see me going around making fun of straight people? C'mon GET OVER IT God made us this way and thats who i am who u gotta be let ure rainbow brites shine! BE PROUD. and i dont give a crap if the Killers are gay or not cos i'd still listen to them cos there a really awesome group. |
USER:
Guest: Antinous :: Iowa |
Date:
2005-08-25 01:18:23 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| First off, I'm gay... and... I'm pagan... so you are entitled you your opinions and all... it doesn't matter what the song is about, because as music is art, you derive your own meanings... I feel this song is about a boy who's high school crush is shunning him because he doesn't want to be open with his sexuality... you may see it differently... hell it may have been intended differently... what matters is that this is a beautiful song... however you look at it... and the Killers are awesome... no matter what their sexuallity... personally if you use the gay twist on Mr. Brightside it makes that song all the more entertaining... you may not agree... but I certainly think so... |
USER:
Guest: Sez n Ang :: Australian |
Date:
2005-09-21 11:46:52 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| WELL dickheads, let us inform of the meaning of this song... (and life) this song is about Brendan Brightside's (AKA Mr. Brightside) friend who he hates called Andie Star, this is evident through the lyrics of the song.... and I quote "Andie you're a f*ck, in everybodys eyes in the world." like.... duh! |
USER:
Guest: THE KILLERS :: HELL (AKA JAPAN) |
Date:
2005-09-21 11:48:44 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| SATAN IS GOD, SO ARE SEZ N ANG... FROM THE KILLERS.... COME TO HELL, ITS ALWAYS SUMMER HERE |
USER:
Guest: candice |
Date:
2005-10-29 18:12:16 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| oh my gosh andy teaches pe at my school!! i'm not even kidding!! i asked him if this song was to him and he said it was!!! i promise he wasn't lying!!!!!! |
USER:
Guest: candice |
Date:
2005-10-29 18:12:30 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| oh my gosh andy teaches pe at my school!! i'm not even kidding!! i asked him if this song was to him and he said it was!!! i promise he wasn't lying!!!!!! |
USER:
Guest: candice |
Date:
2005-10-29 18:19:12 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| and actually... he's not gay! they were just friends! so dont think that! ok? ok. |
USER:
Guest: marshie :: newfane |
Date:
2005-11-30 22:09:09 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| you know what everyone, does it fricken matter weather or not he/they are fricken gay, no! just get over it duh... |
USER:
Guest: amelia :: Brighton |
Date:
2006-01-20 08:40:25 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| this song reminds me of a special person !!!! |
USER:
Guest: darren :: moiki |
Date:
2006-03-06 20:08:16 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| who cares about all this crap! theyre songs aer awsome. if you dont know them dont judge them. |
USER:
Guest: KARLA :: MIAMI BEACH |
Date:
2006-07-27 02:22:41 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| I WANT TO KNO WHAT THE KILLERS REALLY MEAN IN THERE SONGS!!! |
USER:
Guest: Eoin :: Ireland |
Date:
2006-07-23 09:39:40 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| This song isn't just about homosexuality.
It represents the darker, hidden sides of love and infatuation.
The singer is obviously in love with Andy but sees the girl with Andy as an obstacle, but one that he will not let get in his way. |
USER:
Guest: Diggity :: Michigan. |
Date:
2006-04-25 09:34:34 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| First off, I think you're full of shit Candice.
Secondly, I think it's very obviously about homosexuality. |
USER:
Guest: Yuuki Rin Morra :: somewhere |
Date:
2006-09-18 19:17:04 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| Great song!!!!
But did the site have to put that avdertisement right in the middle of the lyrics.... |
USER:
Guest: Emmy :: somewhere over the rainbow |
Date:
2007-02-04 17:04:07 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| wow, to know people who think homosexuality is a bad thing like this song kinda cheapens it for me. |
USER:
Guest: ann :: vzla |
Date:
2007-03-10 19:44:05 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| C´mon are u for real? we´re in 2007, and still tallkin´ about if some man can or can`t be in love with another man? let them be, just be. it´s a great song, and i´m agree whith. Sez n Ang |
USER:
Guest: bEaUtiFuL_BoYz :: Saudi Arabia |
Date:
2007-03-09 15:18:50 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| The song is clearly about Andy Johnson. I read an interview with the band and one of them said that Andy was someone he looked up to |
USER:
Guest: bEaUtiFuL_BoYz :: Saudi Arabia |
Date:
2007-03-09 15:19:17 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| The song is clearly about Andy Johnson. I read an interview with the band and one of them said that Andy was someone he looked up to |
USER:
Guest: kalan :: Canada |
Date:
2007-05-20 14:39:10 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| It is NOT about being a homo!!!
It is about girls holding you back. Go out into the world, live out your capabilities, and don't limit your self expression because a lover wants you near them. Get out of that one horse town, forget the expectations of high school, and become a man, in this case a star. |
USER:
Guest: ingi :: VIC, Aus |
Date:
2007-09-21 04:42:13 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| If there is ONE place where you dont discriminate, it's the music world. People who say the won't listen to music because the band is gay/bi/foreign are a disgrace to anybody who ever liked music. Music is about liking what you hear. Not what you see. Disgraceful, Dylan (CA), Joe (Austin TX). |
USER:
Guest: Patrick :: Nephi Ut. |
Date:
2009-03-05 21:25:12 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| First of all this song isn't about homosexuals. It's far from that, in fact it's about a man named Andy Messersmith, who was friends with Brandon while he lived in Nephi. When Brandon talks about on the field i remember you were incredible- talks about Andy playing football, and on the mats with the boys-talks about Andy wrestling, leave your legacy in gold- is our school color. I know this because Andy is my wrestling and football coach |
USER:
Guest: Patrick :: Nephi Ut. |
Date:
2009-03-05 21:26:50 |
| THE KILLERS - Andy, You're A Star |
| First of all this song isn't about homosexuals. It's far from that, in fact it's about a man named Andy Messersmith, who was friends with Brandon while he lived in Nephi. When Brandon talks about on the field i remember you were incredible- talks about Andy playing football, and on the mats with the boys-talks about Andy wrestling, leave your legacy in gold- is our school color. I know this because Andy is my wrestling and football coach |
Send Andy, You're A Star Ringtone to Cell Phone
Special Offer